Corruption in the Healthcare Sector During the Covid-19 Pandemic: Causes, Consequences and Responses

The purpose of this article is to analyze the main causes of corruption in the healthcare sector during the COVID-19 pandemic. The study identified the main problems of national health during the pandemic, such as theft and resale of state-funded medicines, vaccines, and medical supplies (medical equipment), reduced availability and quality of medical services, low wages of medical workers, limited supervision and control (monitoring) in the healthcare sector and etc. As a result of the analysis, it was concluded that there is a need for additional work to identify cases of those types of corruption that are indicated in the article. Also, citizens should be involved in suppressing corruption in the health sector - documenting all cases of corruption that can be detected at the place of service delivery. They will serve as strong evidence to advocate for transparency and accountability mechanisms that guarantee more equitable access to health services. The authors argue that one of the important recommendations for preventing corruption in the health sector is investing in prevention as well as enforcing it: developing health system reforms and new health programs to reduce incentives and opportunities for corruption. The results showed that the method of statistical analysis is quite effective in the field of studying corruption. The study of the statistics of corruption crimes allows us to adequately characterize the level of corruption. The sources are statistical data of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Combating Corruption, the Bureau of National Statistics, data from international organizations.

1. Lekarstv net, no vy derzhites’ – bol’nye koronavirusom begajut po aptekam Nur-Sultana v poiskah preparatov. URL: https://liter.kz/58353-2/ (data accessed: 24.06.2020).

2. Merton, R.K. (1968). Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: The Free Press.

3. Torsello, D. (2011). The ethnographic study of corruption: research themes in political Anthropology. Quality of Government Institute Working Papers.

4. Yu., Songyeon. (2015). Democracy, Inequality and Corruption. Cambridge University Press.

5. Kossow, N. (2014). The Role of Civil Society in the Fight against Corruption: the Story of Ukraine, Asian NGO. URL: http://issuu.com/asianngo/docs/issue_10_novemberdecember2014. (data accessed: 12.04.2020).

6. Ledeneva, A. (2014). The Ambivalent Future of Ukraine. URL: https://culanth.org/fieldsights/the-ambivalent-future-of-ukraine (data accessed: 11.05.2020).

7. Geveling, L.V. (2001). Kleptokratija. Social’no-politicheskoe izmerenie korrupcii i negativnoj jekonomiki. Bor’ba afrikanskogo gosudarstva s destruktivnymi formami organizacii vlasti. Moskva.

8. Mishin, G.K. (2001). Korrupcija: ponjatie, sushhnost’, mery ogranichenija. Moskva.

9. Smagulov, A.A. (2012). Antikorruptsionnaya politika Respubliki Kazakhstan. Teryaya i istoriya gosudarstva i prava, (2), 15-18.

10. Rakhmetov, S.A. (2017). O khode implementatsii norm mezhdunarodnykh konventsii po voprosam bor’by s korruptsiyey v ugolovnoye zakonodatel’stvo Respubliki Kazakhstan. Vestnik Instituta zakonodatel’stva RK, 2(47), 103-109.

11. Seytkhozhin, B.U. (2014). Kvalifikatsiya korruptsionnykh prestupleniy: teoriya i praktika primeneniya. Karaganda. Izd-vo KEUK.

12. Raisov, U. Ye. (2010). Korruptsiya i yeye sotsial’nyye posledstviya: avtoref. dis.d-ra sotsiol. nauk U. Ye. Raisov, Almaty, 45.

13. Osnovy antikorruptsionnoy kul’tury: uchebnoye posobiye, pod obshchey redaktsiyey d.b.n., professora B. S. Abdrasilova (2016), Astana: Akademiya gosudarstvennogo upravleniya pri Prezidente Respubliki Kazakhstan, 176.

14. Navarrete, M.A. Theft of critical medical equipment surges in Latin America. Insight Crime URL: https://insightcrime.org/news/brief/theftmedical-supplies-latin-america/ (data accessed: 22.04. 2020).

15. Rohrlich, J. An Indiana hospital theft shows face masks and hand sanitizer are now sought as sought-after as drugs. Quartz. URL: https://qz.com/1846475/hospital-cleaner-accusedof-stealing-covid-19-masks-and-sanitizer/ (data accessed: 27.04.2020).

16. Covid-19: Thieves steal 6,000 masks from hospital in Japan. CNA. URL: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/robberthieves-steal-6000-hygiene-masks-japancoronavirus-12446862(data accessed: 18.02.2020).

17. O’Leary, N. Coronavirus: Criminals exploit medical supplies shortage with theft and fraud. Irish Times. URL: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/coronavirus-criminalsexploit-medical-supplies-shortage-with-theft-andfraud-1.4212946 (data accessed: 26.03.2020).

18. 138 medikov zaderzhala policija za prodazhu lekarstv. Tengrinews. URL: https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/138-medikovzaderjala-politsiya-za-prodaju-lekarstv-408801/ (data accessed: 20.07.2020).

19. V Nur-Sultane za vremya karantina vernuli v byudzhet 17 millionov dollarov ot korruptsionnykh prestupleniy. URL: https://www.occrp.org/ru/daily/12270-17-3 (data accessed: 05.05.2020).

20. Shpekbayev o korruptsii vo vremya pandemii: Obogashcheniye na gore svoyego naroda ravnosil’no predatel’stvu i ubiystvu. URL:https://informburo.kz/novosti/shpekbaev-o-korrupcii-vovremya-pandemii-obogashenie-na-gore-svoegonaroda-ravnosilno-predatelstvu-i-ubijstvu (data accessed: 05.04.2021).

21. Ajbolity s bol’shoj dorogi: neizlechimym bol’nym vrachi naznachajut bespoleznye lekarstva. Karavan. URL: https://www.caravan.kz/gazeta/ajjbolity-s-bolshojj-dorogi-neizlechimymbolnym-vrachi-naznachayut-bespoleznyelekarstva-529519/ (data accessed: 01.04.2019).

22. V Shymkente vrachej posadili za moshennichestvo: kazahstancy zaplatili im $300 000. Sputnik. URL: https://ru.sputnik.kz/health/20200916/14978452/V-Shymkentevrachey-posadili-za-moshennichestvo-kazakhstantsy-zaplatili-im-300-000.html (data accessed: 16.09.2020).

23. Italija priostanovit rejsy iz Bangladesh. Ria. URL: https://ria.ru/20200707/1574004853.html (data accessed: 07.07.2020).

24. Lozhnye diagnozy po koronavirusu vydavali laboratorii v VKO. Nurkz. URL:https://www.nur.kz/society/1881577-loznye-diagnozypo-koronavirusu-vydavali-laboratorii-v-vko/ (data accessed: 26.10.2020).

25. Bor’ba s koronavirusnoy infektsiyey, osnashcheniye meditsinskikh organizatsiy, zarplatnaya reforma v medsfere — razvitiye zdravookhraneniya Kazakhstana v 2020 godu. URL: https://primeminister.kz/ru/news/borbas-koronavirusnoy-infekciey-osnashcheniemedicinskih-organizaciy-zarplatnaya-reformav-medsfere-razvitie-zdravoohraneniya-kazahstana-v-2020-godu-121545 (data accessed: 01.06.2021).

26. Transparency Kazakhstan. Monitoring corruption in Kazakhstan for 2020 pod red. Shiyan O.V., Kazakhstan, Almaty (2021), 65.

27. Kratkoye zaklyucheniye k otchetu pravitel’stva respubliki Kazakhstan ob ispolnenii respublikanskogo byudzheta za 2020 god. URL: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/esep/documents/details/167917?lang=ru (data accessed: 02.06.2021).

28. Pochemu gosprogrammy v Kazakhstane ne rabotayut, i kak izmenit’ situatsiyu? URL: https://camonitor.kz/35066-pochemu-gosprogrammy-vkazahstane-ne-rabotayut-i-kak-izmenit-situaciyu.html (data accessed: 11.04.2021).